Our Team

Liberty Title Company of America

Our Team

Whether you’re just starting to look at listings or you’ve already signed a purchase agreement for your dream home, our Liberty Title team members can help walk you through the home purchase process — and then help you keep your home protected with our industry knowledge.

A company is known by the people it keeps

Jonathan Casteleyn


Jonathan has over 20 years of Financial Services experience working for a decade at Bank of America and Wells Fargo and then spending another 10 years as a professional investor in Title, Trust, Fintech, and Asset Management companies. He has a Masters in Analytics from NYU, is a Charter Financial Analyst, and is a Florida Licensed Title Agent.



Operations Manager / Senior Escrow Closer

Phyllis has over a decade of management and closing experience and prides herself on her research process to ensure that closings are conducted in accordance with the highest professional industry standards. Her attention to detail supports her commitment to providing a dynamic closing experience to all Liberty Title Company clients. Phyllis is a Florida native who enjoys going to the movies and spending time with her grandchildren.


Senior Escrow Closer

A Senior Closer with over 10 years of experience, Kelli Ann is a determined and dedicated worker who is skilled at delivering dynamic closing solutions at Liberty Title Company. Kelli Ann is a Florida native and a master cake baker and spends her spare time enjoying theme parks with her children and grandchildren.


Senior Processor

Nicole joined Liberty Title from St. Lucie Title in 2022. Nicole brings a wealth of Processing experience to Liberty after several years supporting multiple Senior Closers in a similar capacity. In addition, Nicole has substantial mortgage and real estate experience with a 15 year tenure at various residential lenders. Nicole is originally from Long Island, NY but moved to Florida 20 years ago and now calls the Sunshine State home.


Senior Processor

Dawn joined Liberty in 2022 as a Senior Processor after a decade in Finance and Technology. Dawn moved to Florida from Chicago and when not working loves watching her two teenage sons play High School Football and competitive Bowling.



Lisa worked for DLF Media Consultants in Port St. Lucie from 2001 to 2020 as Office Manager. Prior to that she was the Bookkeeper/Office Manager for Jetstreme Maintenance, an electrical services business.

Lisa is originally from Connecticut and has lived in St. Lucie County since 1988. In her spare time Lisa enjoys the beach, her pets, and spending time with her family.

Let's Work Together

Let us know how we can help make your real estate transaction a done deal!